Deciding if an Answer is Reasonable Worksheet Download
This worksheet gives a three-part word problem - a total and two of the three parts - along with an answer someone has proposed for the missing part, and asks yes or no: is it reasonable? Every wrong answer on the sheet is the result of a real mistake rather than a random number: the two known parts added together instead of subtracted, one part taken off the total with the other forgotten, or a part added to the total instead of removed. Wrong answers are always either larger than the total, which a single part can never be, or at least double the true value, so the verdict never rests on a close call. Where the other sheets on this standard ask students to compute an answer, this one asks them to judge a result someone else produced, which is the second half of what the standard asks for.